.
.
.
.
Ukraine’s
‘Dr. Strangelove’ Reality
The horrendous fire in Odessa, killing dozens of
ethnic Russians protesting against the U.S.-backed
coup regime in Kiev, has lurched the country closer
to full-scale civil war and disrupted the American
media’s efforts to deny the existence of pro-regime
neo-Nazis.
By Robert Parry at Information Clearing House.
-
As much as the
coup regime in Ukraine and its supporters want to
project an image of Western moderation, there is a
“Dr. Strangelove” element that can’t stop the Nazism
from popping up from time to time, like when the
Peter Sellers character in the classic movie can’t
keep his right arm from making a “Heil Hitler”
salute.
.
This brutal
Nazism surfaced again on Friday when right-wing
toughs in Odessa attacked an encampment of ethnic
Russian protesters driving them into a trade union
building which was then set on fire with Molotov
cocktails. As the building was engulfed in flames,
some people who tried to flee were chased and
beaten, while those trapped inside heard the
Ukrainian nationalists liken them to
black-and-red-striped potato beetles called
Colorados, because those colors are used in
pro-Russian ribbons.
.
“Burn,
Colorado, burn”
went the chant.
.
As the fire
worsened, those dying inside were serenaded with the
taunting singing of the Ukrainian national anthem.
The building also was spray-painted with
Swastika-like symbols and graffiti reading “Galician
SS,” a reference to the Ukrainian nationalist army
that fought alongside the German Nazi SS in World
War II, killing Russians on the eastern front.
.
The death
by fire of dozens of people in Odessa recalled a
World War II incident in 1944 when elements of a
Galician SS police regiment took part in the
massacre of the Polish village of Huta Pieniacka,
which had been a refuge for Jews and was protected
by Russian and Polish partisans. Attacked by a mixed
force of Ukrainian police and German soldiers on
Feb. 28, hundreds of townspeople were massacred,
including many locked in barns that were set ablaze.
.
The legacy
of World War II – especially the bitter fight
between Ukrainian nationalists from the west and
ethnic Russians from the east seven decades ago – is
never far from the surface in Ukrainian politics.
One of the heroes celebrated during the Maidan
protests in Kiev was Nazi collaborator Stepan
Bandera, whose name was honored in many banners
including one on a podium where Sen. John McCain
voiced support for the uprising to oust elected
President Viktor Yanukovych, whose political base
was in eastern Ukraine.
.
During
World War II, Bandera headed the Organization of
Ukrainian Nationalists-B, a radical paramilitary
movement that sought to transform Ukraine into a
racially pure state. OUN-B took part in the
expulsion and extermination of thousands of Jews and
Poles.
.
Though most
of the Maidan protesters in 2013-14 appeared
motivated by anger over political corruption and by
a desire to join the European Union, neo-Nazis made
up a significant number. These storm troopers from
the Right Sektor and Svoboda party decked out some
of the occupied government buildings with Nazi
insignias and even
a Confederate battle flag, the universal symbol
of white supremacy.
.
Then, as
the protests turned violent from Feb. 20-22, the
neo-Nazis surged to the forefront. Their
well-trained militias, organized in 100-man brigades
called “the hundreds,” led the final assaults
against police and forced Yanukovych and many of his
officials to flee for their lives.
.
In the days
after the coup, as the neo-Nazi militias effectively
controlled the government, European and U.S.
diplomats scrambled to help the shaken parliament
put together the semblance of a respectable regime,
although
four ministries, including national security,
were awarded to the right-wing extremists in
recognition of their crucial role in ousting
Yanukovych.
.
Seeing
No Nazis
.
Since
February, virtually the entire U.S. news media has
cooperated in the effort to play down the neo-Nazi
role, dismissing any mention of this inconvenient
truth as “Russian propaganda.” Stories in the U.S.
media delicately step around the neo-Nazi reality by
keeping out relevant context, such as the background
of national security chief Andriy Parubiy, who
founded the Social-National Party of Ukraine in
1991, blending radical Ukrainian nationalism with
neo-Nazi symbols. Parubiy was commandant of the
Maidan’s “self-defense forces.”
.
When the
neo-Nazi factor is mentioned in the mainstream U.S.
press, it is usually to dismiss it as nonsense, such
as an April 20 column by New York Times columnist
Nicholas Kristof who visited his ancestral home, the
western Ukrainian town of Karapchiv, and portrayed
its residents as the true voice of the Ukrainian
people.
.
“To
understand why Ukrainians are risking war with
Russia to try to pluck themselves from Moscow’s
grip, I came to this village where my father grew
up,” he wrote. “Even here in the village, Ukrainians
watch Russian television and loathe the propaganda
portraying them as neo-Nazi thugs rampaging against
Russian speakers.
.
“‘If you
listen to them, we all carry assault rifles; we’re
all beating people,’ Ilya Moskal, a history teacher,
said contemptuously.”
.
In
an April 17 column from Kiev, Kristof wrote that
what the Ukrainians want is weapons from the West so
they can to go “bear-hunting,” i.e. killing
Russians. “People seem to feel a bit disappointed
that the United States and Europe haven’t been more
supportive, and they are humiliated that their own
acting government hasn’t done more to confront
Russian-backed militants. So, especially after a few
drinks, people are ready to take down the Russian
Army themselves.”
.
Kristof
also repeated the U.S. “conventional wisdom” that
the resistance to the coup regime among eastern
Ukrainians was entirely the work of Russian
President Vladimir Putin, who, Kristof wrote, “warns
that Ukraine is on the brink of civil war. But the
chaos in eastern cities is his own creation, in part
by sending provocateurs across the border.”
.
However,
when the New York Times finally sent two reporters
to spend time with rebels from the east, they
encountered an indigenous movement motivated by
hostility to the Kiev regime and showing no signs of
direction from Moscow. [See Consortiumnews.com’s “Another
NYT ‘Sort of’ Retraction on Ukraine.”]
.
Beyond the
journalistic risk of jumping to conclusions,
Kristof, who fancies himself a great humanitarian,
also should recognize that the clever depiction of
human beings as animals, whether as “bears” or
“Colorado beetles,” can have horrendous human
consequences as is now apparent in Odessa.
.
Reagan’s
Nazis
.
But the
problem with some western Ukrainians expressing
their inconvenient love for Nazis has not been
limited to the current crisis. It bedeviled Ronald
Reagan’s administration when it began heating up the
Cold War in the 1980s.
.
As part of
that strategy, Reagan’s United States Information
Agency, under his close friend Charles Wick, hired a
cast of right-wing Ukrainian exiles who began
showing up on U.S.-funded Radio Liberty praising the
Galician SS.
.
These
commentaries included positive depictions of
Ukrainian nationalists who had sided with the Nazis
in World War II as the SS waged its “final solution”
against European Jews. The propaganda broadcasts
provoked outrage from Jewish organizations, such as
B’nai B’rith, and individuals including conservative
academic Richard Pipes.
.
According
to an internal memo dated May 4, 1984, and written
by James Critchlow, a research officer at the Board
of International Broadcasting, which managed Radio
Liberty and Radio Free Europe, one RL broadcast in
particular was viewed as “defending Ukrainians who
fought in the ranks of the SS.”
Critchlow
wrote, “An RL Ukrainian broadcast of Feb. 12, 1984
contains references to the Nazi-oriented
Ukrainian-manned SS ‘Galicia’ Division of World War
II which may have damaged RL’s reputation with
Soviet listeners. The memoirs of a German diplomat
are quoted in a way that seems to constitute
endorsement by RL of praise for Ukrainian volunteers
in the SS division, which during its existence
fought side by side with the Germans against the Red
Army.”
.
Harvard
Professor Pipes, who was an informal adviser to the
Reagan administration, also inveighed against the
Radio Liberty broadcasts, writing – on Dec. 3, 1984
– “the Russian and Ukrainian services of RL have
been transmitting this year blatantly anti-Semitic
material to the Soviet Union which may cause the
whole enterprise irreparable harm.”
.
Though the
Reagan administration publicly defended Radio
Liberty against some of the public criticism,
privately some senior officials agreed with the
critics, according to documents in the archives of
the Reagan Presidential Library in Simi Valley,
California. For instance, in a Jan. 4, 1985, memo,
Walter Raymond Jr., a top official on the National
Security Council, told his boss, National Security
Adviser Robert McFarlane, that “I would believe much
of what Dick [Pipes] says is right.”
.
What the
Reagan administration apparently didn’t understand
three decades ago – and what the U.S. State
Department still has not seemed to learn today – is
that there is a danger in stirring up the old
animosities that divide Ukraine, east and west.
.
Though
clearly a minority, Ukraine’s neo-Nazis remain a
potent force that is well-organized, well-motivated
and prone to extreme violence, whether throwing
firebombs at police in the Maidan or at ethnic
Russians trapped in a building in Odessa.
As
vengeance now seeks vengeance across Ukraine, this
Nazi imperative will be difficult to hold down, much
as Dr.
.
Strangelove struggled to stop his arm from
making a “Heil Hitler” salute.
____________________________
Investigative reporter Robert Parry broke many of
the Iran-Contra stories for The Associated Press and
Newsweek in the 1980s. You can buy his new book,
America’s Stolen Narrative, either in print
here or as an e-book (from
Amazon and
barnesandnoble.com). For a limited time, you
also can order Robert Parry’s trilogy on the Bush
Family and its connections to various right-wing
operatives for only $34. The trilogy includes
America’s Stolen Narrative. For details on this
offer,
click here.